Rhetorical Questions with 谁, 什么, 哪儿 and 怎么
Use question words to make strong statements, like 谁不想去？ “Who wouldn’t want to go?” and 我哪儿知道？ “How would I know?”
Padrão
谁/什么/哪儿/怎么 + question with no answer expected (often ending in 呢)
A rhetorical question flips the meaning: 谁知道？ = nobody knows, 谁不知道？ = everybody knows.
谁不想去旅游呢？
When to use Rhetorical Questions with 谁, 什么, 哪儿 and 怎么
A question with 谁, 什么, 哪儿 or 怎么 can be a strong statement instead of a real question. The meaning flips: a positive question means “nobody / nothing / not at all”, and a negative one means “everybody / of course”. So 谁知道？ means “nobody knows”, while 谁不想去？ means “everyone wants to go”. The question word stays where it would be in a normal question, and 呢 at the end often adds feeling.
我怎么知道他去哪儿了？
How would I know where he went? (= I have no idea)
我哪儿有那么多钱？
Where would I get that much money? (= I don’t have it)
谁说我不会做饭？
Who says I can’t cook? (= I can)
你急什么？时间还早呢。
What’s the rush? It’s still early. (= don’t hurry)
Erros comuns
- For “no need to…”, put 什么 after the verb: 你哭什么？, not 你什么哭？.
- For “how could you…”, say 怎么能 + verb: 你怎么能不告诉我？, not 你怎么不能告诉我？ (that asks why you’re unable to).
- When the question word carries the question, don’t add 吗: 谁知道？, not 谁知道吗？.
Exercício direcionado
Pratique exatamente este padrão antes de avançar.
Mantenha este padrão em revisão.
Você acabou de praticar um cartão de gramática real. Crie uma conta para salvar esta estrutura e depois escolha um plano para continuar revisando. Todos os planos têm garantia de reembolso de 30 dias.
US$ 9,99
Mensal
Por mês
Melhor valor
US$ 49,99
Ilimitado anual
Por ano
US$ 119,99
Vitalício
Pagamento único